simplehuman Toilet Plunger with Holder Set, Magnetic Drip-Free Cover, Narrow Flange for Modern Low-Flow Toilets, Hidden Dome Storage, Stainless Steel, White

Why it's worth it

The simplehuman disappears into a low dome, and a magnetic collar locks the cover to the steel rod so it travels to the bowl with you. Its narrow flange is built for the tighter drain openings on modern low-flow toilets.

The magnetic collar stops drips where they actually happen. Most holders catch drips while the plunger sits still. The mess usually happens in the three steps between the toilet and the caddy. simplehuman's cover clamps to the stainless rod and rides along with the plunger, so whatever's dripping lands inside the cover instead of on your tile.

It's the only one here that doesn't read as a plunger. The dome sits low and hides the head completely, with a large rear opening you reach into to pull the tool out. In a guest bathroom or a fresh renovation, that's the whole point. Nobody notices it, which is exactly what you want.

From our review of 8 heavy-duty toilet plungers, by David Sinclair, Managing Editor

What we like

• +The magnetic collar stops drips where they actually happen
• +It's the only one here that doesn't read as a plunger
• +The narrow flange is aimed at modern low-flow bowls
• +The build quality shows in the details you touch

What to know

• –It's the most expensive plunger here, and the money buys looks
• –That narrow flange struggles on older toilets